Positive EFSA appraisal of dry grape extract

© istock.com/Hyrma

EFSA has found there is no requirement to show efficacy for a dry grape extract for use in livestock feed due its flavoring components.

The additive, a mixture of two extracts from seeds and the skin of Vitis vinifera subsp. Vinifera, contains, as its dominant constituent, the proanthocyanidin-rich seed extract, which is recognized to provide flavor in food, and its function in feed would “be essentially the same” concluded the Parma based European Food Safety Authority (EFSA).

The EU risk assessor’s FEEDAP Panel determined that the dry grape extract is safe at the maximum proposed use level —100 mg/kg complete feed — for all animal species except dogs, for which no safe dietary concentration could be established.

EFSA also found there were no safety concerns for the consumer from the use of the dry grape extract up to the highest safe level in feeds. The panel decided the use of dry grape extract at the maximum proposed dose is not a risk for the environment.

Full opinion delayed

For now, only the abstract part of the scientific opinion on the dry grape extract has been published.

An EFSA spokesperson said the partial publication of the opinion arose from the fact the applicant company claimed that some parts were confidential, a move in line with article 18(2) of the Regulation (EC) No 1831/2003.

“In these cases we wait for the EU Commission to inform us of their decision [in relation to the] applicant’s claim. Only after having considered this decision, we publish a redacted version omitting the paragraphs claimed as confidential, if they do not relate to safety issues,” she said.

She said, as yet, EFSA has no indication as to when it will receive that decision on confidentiality from the EU executive. 

Technological, nutritional and sensory additives, including the flavourings, are generic, so if the extract is authorised, it will be as a generic additive, noted the spokesperson.

Dossier background

The question number included in the opinion corresponds to a dossier submitted by French botanicals firm, Nor Feed, back in 2010.

CEO of that Angers headquartered company, Olivier Clech, yesterday told us the EFSA opinion was “positive”.

He said Nor Feed had asked that, for competition purposes, no data should be released in relation to how it ensures consistency in its extracts, hence the delay in publication of the remainder of the document.

The French producer had requested ‘flavoring additive’ status for its dry grape extract to try and secure EU authorization, said Clech. “It is the entry level claim for plant extracts,” he said.

Clech said it and other plant extract producers had been told by the Commission that authorizations related to botanicals were very much put to the back of the line in the evaluation process due to their low risk profile.

“It has taken us almost six years to get to this stage. Of course, we are awaiting the final opinion of the Commission but we think we are at the end of the process,” added the CEO.

Nor Feed, he said, did all the work on the dossier. It purposely did not submit an application in combination with other plant extract producers, he continued. “A lot of those consortium led additive authorization applications have failed due, we think, to the fact that they are trying to bind together a combination of different types of extracts,” said Clech.

Nor Feed also submitted dossiers on a citrus extract and Melissa extract back in 2010.

The EFSA opinion on the dry grape extract can be read here. 

Related News

© iStock/VasilySmirnov

Butyrate, botanicals and yeast cell walls – how can they be made more effective?

© istock/nikkytok

Tannins and tapeworm thesis awarded Nor Feed botanicals prize

© istock

‘Phytogenics are moving from niche to mainstream’

© istock

Nor Feed gets EU thumbs-up for its dry grape extract

© iStock.com

Essential oils, diet may boost piglet growth, gut health

Process ensures standardization and reliability of plant extracts: Nor Feed Sud

Nor Feed Sud hails technology that eliminates any 'variability' in plant extracts

The move away from the use of AGPs in poultry production has triggered huge interest in essential oils in feed: review © istock.com/JPC-PROD

Review claims multiple modes of action for essential oils in poultry production

EU: Imported tocopherols must undergo 100% batch dioxin testing

EU: Imported tocopherols must undergo 100% batch dioxin testing

Benefits of essential oils outlined but review shows lack of understanding of their mode of action

Benefits of essential oils outlined but review shows lack of understanding of their mode of action

Benefits of natural antioxidants ‘go way beyond’ their use as partial Vit E replacers in feed, says Cargill

Benefits of natural antioxidants ‘go way beyond’ their use as partial Vit E replacers in feed, says Cargill

‘The breadth and depth of the submissions was staggering’  Nor Feed talks awards and growth strategy

‘The breadth and depth of the submissions was staggering’ Nor Feed talks awards and growth strategy

Plant extracts research recognition should stimulate scientific tie-ups: Nor-Feed Sud

Plant extracts research recognition should stimulate scientific tie-ups: Nor-Feed Sud

© istock.com/semakokal

Vietnam: Nor Feed to capitalize on shift away from antibiotic growth promoters

French botanical feed firm looks to Morocco and Tunisia after Algerian push

French botanical feed firm looks to Morocco and Tunisia after Algerian push

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.