'Benefit perception was generally stronger than risk perception' finds survey evaluating market acceptance of insect derived feed

'Benefit perception was generally stronger than risk perception' finds survey evaluating market acceptance of insect derived feed

A newly published survey of farmers, agriculture sector stakeholders and consumers shows attitudes towards the idea of using insects in animal feed were generally favorable.

Fish and poultry feed topped the charts in terms of most likely livestock sectors to use insect derived protein, followed by pig feed, and to a lower extent pet food and cattle feed, found the research team, based at Ghent University’s Faculty of Bioscience Engineering.

The authors noted use of processed animal protein (PAP) from non-ruminant animals, including insects, was re-authorized for feeding farmed fish under EU regulation as of June 2013 and that an extension of that ruling to pig and poultry feed might be considered this year.

According to their findings, published in Animal Feed Science and Technology, insect feed was perceived to be more sustainable and to have a better nutritive value for animals but a lower microbiological safety as compared to conventional feed.

Benefits and risks

And benefit perception was generally stronger than risk perception, said the authors.

They reported the strongest perceived benefits of using insects in feed pertained to lowering the EU livestock industry’s dependence on foreign protein sources and better use of organic waste.

The perceived risks, generally, were about possible impacts on biodiversity in case of accidental release of non-native insects and about the introduction of microbiological hazards in the food chain, they added.

The potential of insects, both as food and in feed as an alternative to fishmeal, fish oil and soymeal, has been widely acknowledged recently, with the Belgian research team citing the 2013 report Edible insects’ published by the UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), in this regard.

That report recognized that, despite the large potential of insects, insect rearing for food and feed remains a sector in its infancy and key future challenges will likely emerge as the field evolves.

The Ghent-based researchers said one such challenge pertains to future marketplace acceptance - the prompt, thus, for this study.

“While feed companies in the Netherlands have committed to include insects in their livestock feed and have everything in place to take off as soon as EU legislation allows them to do so, little is known about the reactions of farmers, stakeholders and citizen/consumers towards the use of insects in animal feed.

Such reactions are likely to determine the future success of using insect based feed for different species,” said the authors.

The survey

They carried out the survey in January this year in Flanders, the northern Dutch-speaking region of Belgium, which has a highly specialized intensive livestock farming industry accounting for 6.15 million pigs, 30.75 million units of poultry, and 1.25 million units of cattle – both dairy and beef.

Participants were recruited from the visitors of a Flemish agricultural fair involving exhibitors covering all main sectors of agriculture, including feed and feed additives, and attracting about 80,000 visitors, said the team.

They interviewed 196 farmers as well as 137 stakeholders from diverse sectors linked to agriculture, covering the animal feed and livestock sector industries, as well as government, consultancy, finance and research institutions. In addition, they said 82 visitors who indicated to be neither directly nor indirectly involved in agriculture took part in the poll.

Participants had to complete an electronic survey in relation to their attitudes, product attribute beliefs, perceived benefits, risks and concerns, and willingness to accept and use insect derived animal feed.

The authors reported that the idea of using insects in animal feed was rejected by only 17% of those polled.

Findings indicate momentum for change’

This finding corresponds with the insights from the baseline PROteINSECT survey of October 2013 to March 2014, which found that a similar proportion of a sample of 1,302 participants with diverse backgrounds believed that ‘larvae of flies are a suitable source of protein for use in animal feed.’

But the Ghent authors concluded: “Farmers in general and livestock farmers with ruminants in particular, were more critical towards the use of insects in animal feed than agriculture sector stakeholders or citizens. This is consistent with the farmers’ weaker perception of benefits and stronger perception of risks associated with the use of insects in animal feed.”

Livestock products from animals fed insect derived feed were perceived to be more sustainable, nutritious and healthy, but at risk of presence of off-flavors and allergens, and less easily marketable, found the team.

Eggs and poultry meat from animals fed on insect-based diets were rejected by 17% of the study sample; beef and milk from cattle fed on insect-based diets were rejected by 25% of participants.

The authors concluded the findings of this study “indicate a positive atmosphere and momentum for change towards the adoption of insects as a new ingredient in animal feed.”

Source: Animal Feed Science and Technology

Published online ahead of print: doi:10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2015.04.001
Title: Insects in animal feed: Acceptance and its determinants among farmers, agriculture sector stakeholders and citizens
Authors: W. Verbeke, T. Spranghers, P. De Clercq, S. De Smet, B. SAS,  and M. Eeckhout

Related News

UK team shows insect feed comparable to fishmeal

UK team shows insect feed comparable to fishmeal

EU report provides more ammo for insect feed case

EU report provides more ammo for insect feed case

Insect meal may offer sustainable, AA-rich poultry feed

Insect meal may offer sustainable, AA-rich poultry feed

EFSA insect protein safety assessment imminent

EFSA insect protein safety assessment imminent

Poll shows EU consumers have high acceptance of insect derived protein in feed

Poll shows EU consumers have high acceptance of insect derived protein in feed

© istock.com/CreativeNature_nl

'An important stepping stone in furthering our understanding of the potential of insects as a protein source' - long awaited EFSA opinion out

PROteINSECT said its fish feeding trials demonstrated insect meal can replace up to 50% of feed without affecting animal performance.                                         Image © istock.com/pichet_w

PROteINSECT: 'The process towards adoption of insect protein in feed (in the EU) is already underway'

© istock.com/pepsikan

ForFarmers explores potential for mycotoxin, heavy metal accumulation in insect meal

Black soldier fly © Enterra Feed Corporation

Enterra gets Canadian regulatory backing for insect larvae in chicken feed

© istock/pepsikan

60 second interview: InnovaFeed bitten by the bug

'Protix showed us how big an opportunity insect protein is' - Bühler © Protix

Bühler and Protix align for 'breakthrough' in large scale insect production

© istock/Zerbor

EU insect meal manufacturers look beyond fish

© istock

FAO wants views on how to best benchmark feed risk assessment

© istock/Kenishirotie

FAO carrying out survey on contaminants in feed

Insects billed as feed of the future

Insects billed as feed of the future

© istock.com/CreativeNature_nl

Insect feed producers align to remove EU regulatory roadblocks

Insects for feed: regulation must keep pace with industry needs, says expert

Insects for feed: regulation must keep pace with industry needs, says expert

Black soldier fly larvae are emerging as a promising animal feed source. Photo courtesy of Gill Hampshire.

Insect meals could replace up to 100% of conventional protein source in animal feeds, say researchers

EU approval for insect derived pig and poultry feed may be six months away

EU approval for insect derived pig and poultry feed may be six months away

Safety evaluation of insects for feed - EFSA scientists want terms of reference reviewed

Safety evaluation of insects for feed - EFSA scientists want terms of reference reviewed

Insects and algae top the line-up in future feed ingredients for pigs

Insects and algae top the line-up in future feed ingredients for pigs

© istock.com/CreativeNature_nl

'Legislators are right not to rush into allowing insects enter the food chain' - expert reveals findings showing heavy metals in flies reared on waste

AgriProtein expects to yield 7 tons daily of its larvae derived meal by August this year

‘We will follow friendly legislation around the world’ - Insect feed maker, AgriProtein, says logic will win out in the EU

Barentz sees huge potential in insect derived protein meal for animal feed

Insects, bacteria and new amino acids: will NPD push Barentz into pole position in Europe?

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.